UltimateDisney.com | DVDizzy.com: DVD & Blu-ray Release Schedule | DVD Reviews | Upcoming Cover Art | Search This Site
Grey's Anatomy on DVD: Season 1 • Season 2 • Season 3 • Season 4 • Season 5
"Grey's Anatomy": Complete Fifth Season - More Moments DVD Review - Page 2
Buy Grey's Anatomy from Amazon.com: Season 5 DVD • Seasons 1-5 DVD • Pre-order Season 5 Blu-ray
Disc 4
13. Stairway to Heaven (49:26) (Originally aired January 22, 2009)
14. Beat Your Heart Out (43:00) (Originally aired February 5, 2009)
15. Before and After (43:00) (Originally aired February 12, 2009)
16. An Honest Mistake (43:02) (Originally aired February 19, 2009)
Disc 5
17. I Will Follow You Into the Dark (43:01) (Originally aired March 12, 2009)
18. Stand By Me (42:59) (Originally aired March 19, 2009)
19. Elevator Love Letter (43:03) (Originally aired March 26, 2009)
20. Sweet Surrender (43:04) (Originally aired April 23, 2009)
Disc 6
21. No Good at Saying Sorry (One More Chance) (43:01) (Originally aired April 30, 2009)
22. What a Difference a Day Makes (43:01) (Originally aired May 7, 2009)
23. Here's to Future Days (43:00) (Originally aired May 14, 2009)
24. Now or Never (43:01) (Originally aired May 14, 2009)
VIDEO and AUDIO
Whatever you may think of the show itself from week to week, its DVDs are presented in fine quality. As always, all episodes are presented in 1.78:1 anamorphic widescreen, the aspect ratio of their original high-definition broadcasts. As to be expected from a new television program coming to DVD, the quality is basically perfect and there are no issues to be reported with either the video or audio (which is in Dolby Digital 5.1). Those who own the previous seasons should know exactly what to expect here, as the set delivers more of the same in terms of transfer quality. This season was to be released simultaneously on Disney's favorite format, Blu-ray, but that release has been delayed indefinitely. Since "Grey's" does not deliver the same kind of lush eye candy as, say, ABC schedule mate "Lost", the value of the high-definition version may not be as significant and comes down to your personal preferences. I personally love Blu-ray, but feel no need to have "Grey's" in that format.
BONUS FEATURES, MENUS and PACKAGING
With the exception of the extended episode "Stairway to Heaven" on Disc Four, all bonus features are reserved for Disc 7.
"100th Episode: Tales From the O.R." (18:31) is the most insightful feature, using the milestone as a springboard for a making-of featurette that could apply to any episode. We see footage of the initial table read and the 100th episode party, and hear from the directors, editor and cast about their various parts of the show. Also present in interviews are creator Shonda Rhimes and executive producer Betsy Beers. There is, of course, some self-congratulation here That's not so much the case for "Heaven Sent" (9:29), a featurette on Jeffrey Dean Morgan's Denny that seems only to exist for the self-congratulation. Writers talk about his arcs in both Seasons Two and Five and emphasize that they had a plan for his reappearance, but do not acknowledge that the plan was fundamentally flawed. Worse, featured clips from Season Two only serve to demonstrate how much better the show was then, back when you still cared about what happened to this character.
There is also a healthy collection of deleted scenes (17:28) from various episodes which were not restored and the outtakes reel (4:04), both of which are worth watching but not in any way revolutionary. The deletions include commentary with Rhimes and Beers, who did not record any commentaries on full episodes this year.
Five years down the line, pretty much everything on this DVD seems rather routine because each season set is modeled similarly. Things that were innovative and unique on the first season or two seem a little like a rerun now; even if they are not necessarily bad quality, there is a feeling that we've seen most of this before. Still, because the writers remain unwilling to acknowledge and examine the mistakes they made this year, this is probably the best set of extras that could have been produced.
Also of note: playing automatically with Disc 1's Play All option (the only apparent way to access it) is an "ABC Starter Kit" (4:44) intended to bring viewers up to speed on the show. It's a nice inclusion in theory, but the chances of someone buying the fifth season and not knowing everything discussed here are pretty slim. Also, since this was produced to catch people up for Season Six, it covers certain plot developments from Season Five. So it's probably best to skip if you haven't already seen the season in full; the one they produced prior to Season 5's start would have been a better inclusion here.
What is not included on this set is more troubling. The episodes of "Private Practice" involved in the February crossover contain scenes vital to the overlapping storyline's progression. Without them, the set is kind of incomplete. While this technically supplies every 2008-09 episode of "Grey's Anatomy", the point of a season set is to allow the viewer to watch the season's stories unfold in their entirety, and there are significant holes with those episodes absent. Like the previous three seasons, "Grey's" comes in a Digipak that folds out to contain several panels; one lists the episodes and holds promotional inserts (there aren't any pertaining to this set). The others house the discs overlappingly. The promotional inserts do their best to sell you on other ABC TV box sets on DVD (including a $10 off coupon for other new releases of last season's programming) and on the advantages of upgrading to Blu-ray. There is not, however, an offer to receive money back if you upgrade this set to its concurrent Blu-ray release, as there was for Season Four box set. Disc 1 opens with several trailers, including one for the concurrent "Private Practice" release. Additional ads can be found on Disc Seven.
CLOSING THOUGHTS
Overall, the fifth season of "Grey's Anatomy" can be characterized as its most woeful to date. In promos, ABC is billing the imminently-debuting Season Six as "the season that changes everything." While that is probably just fancy marketing, it's hard not to notice that change (hopefully back to its more focused former self) may actually benefit the show, since its status quo is so hit-and-miss.
Because of the show's mixed quality this year, this is a hard DVD to recommend, but the episodes are presented in fine transfers and, though, unexceptional, most of the bonus features merit a look. Hardcore "Grey's" fans will want it in their collection anyway and can take heart in their ability to fast-forward through the junk to get to the good stuff.
More on the DVD / Buy from Amazon.com / Buy Seasons 1-5 on DVD / Pre-order on Blu-ray
|
Related Reviews:
UltimateDisney.com | DVDizzy.com: DVD & Blu-ray Release Schedule | DVD Reviews | Upcoming Cover Art | Search This Site
Grey's Anatomy: Season Three • Grey's Anatomy: The Complete Second Season • Grey's Anatomy: Season One
Scrubs: Season 1 • Season 2 • Season 3 • Season 4 • Season 5 • Season 6 • Season 7 • Season 8
Desperate Housewives: The Complete Fifth Season • Brothers & Sisters: The Complete Third Season • Ugly Betty: The Complete Third Season
Castle: The Complete First Season • Dirty Sexy Money: The Complete (and Final) Second Season • Eli Stone: The Complete Second Season
Army Wives: The Complete Second Season • Pushing Daisies: The Complete First Season • Raising the Bar: The Complete First Season
He's Just Not That Into You • Everything You Want • Confessions of a Shopaholic • Swing Vote
Featuring The Cast of Grey's Anatomy: Enchanted • Knocked Up • Marley & Me • The Night Listener
Written by Creator Shonda Rhimes: The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement
Reviewed September 23, 2009.
UltimateDisney.com/DVDizzy.com Top Stories:
Text copyright 2009 DVDizzy.com. Images copyright 2008-09 ShondaLand, The Mark Gordon Company, and ABC Studios, 2009 Buena Vista Home Entertainment.
Unauthorized reproduction prohibited.