^ I guess that makes sense. Creating the little pocket of air they live in likely took a much longer amount of time.
DisneyFan09 wrote: Mole is annoying and frankly the side characters are more interesting than Milo.
I actually never found Mole annoying, although I know a lot of people I’ve discussed the film/character with have had the same opinion as you over the years. I find most of his moments pretty funny, the ending where he burrows into a vase in particular makes me die laughing every time I sit through the movie.
But I agree about the rest of the cast being more interesting than Milo. That isn’t a knock on Milo at all for me, considering I find him to be adorable and one of Disney’s better protagonists. My favorite of the crew has always been Mrs. Packard. It wasn’t until recently than I re-watched Jim Henson’s
Dinosaurs for the first time with adult eyes, and that’s when I connected the voice here with the grandmother on that show. The familiarity with that character (who was my favorite along with the baby on
Dinosaurs) may be partly why Packard is my favorite here. I love the moment where she has to be forced to put down the phone on her friend’s melodramatic lovelife when the submarine is on the verge of being destroyed.
I think I like Cookie for a similar reason, because I grew up watching Ernest films and so Jim Varney’s voice is recognizable. My favorite after Packard is Vinny, but Audrey and Sweet are great,too.
And I agree about Helga, too. I’ve always found her more interesting than Rourke (although Rourke is a strong villain with a fantastic design, imo), but she definitely seems more in the background than the other characters, all of whom at least get their little moments to shine.
I couldn’t help thinking last night how much I wish this had succeeded at the time. I can’t guess why it failed. If I had to guess, I’d blame the marketing which put too much focus on the too in-depth mythology and sci-fi aspect (considering Disney has always been more fantastical than sci-fi). Which is odd considering
Treasure Planet was marketed in the entirely opposite direction, putting focus on the worst part of the film—those ugly, stupid aliens, and of course the farting one most of all… I definitely think
Atlantis is objectively the better film between the two, although I do like Jim Hawkins more than anything in
Atlantis.
I’ve never watched the DTV sequel,
Milo’s Return, and I almost want to just to hear the reprises of several of the voice actors. That’s my main disappointment in
Atlantis and TP’s failures—I would’ve loved to have seen more of the characters here and Jim Hawkins, which we would’ve got considering the franchises Disney had been prepared to launch for them.
Btw, I'm grateful I have the Collector's Edition 2-Disc for this (and for TENG). I'm glad this film got pretty great treatment at least once.