Thumbelina vs. The Swan Princess vs. Anastasia

Discussion of non-Disney entertainment.
User avatar
Linden
Special Edition
Posts: 672
Joined: Thu Sep 16, 2010 11:24 am
Location: United States Gender: Female

Post by Linden »

Cordy_Biddle wrote:In the original "Anastasia" play by Guy Bolton and Marcelle Maurette (on which the animated movie is partly based), the Anastasia character also makes a very swift exit with no formal goodbye to her grandmother. I find this quite unsatisfying, but it adds to the tone of the piece, I suppose.
Oh, that makes more sense. I guess I don't have to blame it on animated Anastasia, then. Just on the playwrights. :P
User avatar
Prince Edward
Anniversary Edition
Posts: 1184
Joined: Fri Jun 27, 2008 9:23 pm
Location: Trondheim, Norway
Contact:

Post by Prince Edward »

I love Anastasia! The story, the animation, the atmosphere/setting and especially the music and the songs.

The Swan Princess is also good, I think it's a very funny movie. And I like the songs/soundtrack for this one as well.

Thumbelina has wondeful songs as well, but the story and animation is not so wonderous.

I have them all on DVD, and can't wait for Anastasia to be released on Blu-ray someday!
Favorite Disney-movies: Snow White, Cinderella, Alice in Wonderland, Sleeping Beauty, The Little Mermaid, Beauty and the Beast, Aladdin, Pocahontas, The Hunchback of Notre Dame, Hercules, Mulan, Tarzan, Tangled, Frozen, Pirates, Enchanted, Prince of Persia, Tron, Oz The Great and Powerful
User avatar
Cordy_Biddle
Anniversary Edition
Posts: 1597
Joined: Tue Nov 23, 2004 2:02 am
Location: the balcony of the Bijou...

Post by Cordy_Biddle »

Linden wrote:
Cordy_Biddle wrote:In the original "Anastasia" play by Guy Bolton and Marcelle Maurette (on which the animated movie is partly based), the Anastasia character also makes a very swift exit with no formal goodbye to her grandmother. I find this quite unsatisfying, but it adds to the tone of the piece, I suppose.
Oh, that makes more sense. I guess I don't have to blame it on animated Anastasia, then. Just on the playwrights. :P
In the play, Anastasia leaves just before she's due to make her royal debut. Her Grandmother is asked what she'll say at the reception to explain Anastasia's absence, and her airy reply, "The play is over--go home!"
I'm just valentine candy and boxing-gloves!

My DVD Collection :
http://classic-movieguy.dvdaf.com/
User avatar
Sky Syndrome
Anniversary Edition
Posts: 1187
Joined: Sat Jan 21, 2006 3:07 am
Location: Maine

Post by Sky Syndrome »

I wish Anastasia's soundtrack CD would get reissued with more score tracks. I want the score tracks for the hijacked train scene and the final confrontation with Rasputin! I can't believe there are two variants of the Journey to the Past song and a variant of the Once Upon a December song taking up room that could have been for other memorable score tracks. Those variant songs together take up 10 minutes and 45 seconds!
Image
User avatar
BelleGirl
Anniversary Edition
Posts: 1174
Joined: Thu Oct 18, 2007 2:36 am
Location: The Netherlands, The Hague

Post by BelleGirl »

I'ts a long time ago I saw Thumbelina but I remember I did not like it (thought it was lame) I've only seen a small part of The swan princess so I cannot properly judge but the animation was only so-so in my remembrance. Artistically I consider Anastasia as the best by far... still I would never feel the urge to purchase any of the three movies to add it to my dvd collection.

Compare Anastasia to Pocahontas for historical inaccuracy I would say the first one is 99.99% inaccurate and the second one 'only' 98%. :roll:
Image

See my growing collection of Disney movie-banners at:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/78256383@N ... 651337290/
well
Member
Posts: 2
Joined: Wed Feb 23, 2011 7:47 pm
Contact:

Post by well »

I actually wrote two articles about the production of "The Swan Princess" and "Thumbelina"(And soon, one about Anastasia). You can check them out -> www.theredanimation.canalblog.com !

As for my vote, I would not know what to say, I like the three of them but different moods, sometimes I love "The swan princess", sometimes I just hate it and it is like that for the others too. I guess that these movies are pretty good but have a lot of flaws that cannot make me love them on a regular basis. [/url]
User avatar
bradhig
Anniversary Edition
Posts: 1109
Joined: Thu Apr 07, 2005 10:59 pm
Location: Olathe , Kansas

Post by bradhig »

Once Anastasia had been reunited with her grandmother Dimitri wasn't needed anymore. Anastasia could have handled Rasputin by herself. She did get back up on the bridge after part of it collapsed somehow? Maybe she had a tardis stashed nearby.
User avatar
Rose Dome
Special Edition
Posts: 637
Joined: Mon May 23, 2011 6:28 pm
Location: Sydney (Australia)

Post by Rose Dome »

Widdi wrote:The picture of Rasputin's corpse laying on the ground with the bullet hole in his head (that is on his Wikipedia page), scares me more than any picture I've seen of him alive.

Seriously scary man.


AAAAAAAGGGGGGHHHHH!!!!!!! :o :shock: :huh:

I knew Rasputin was scary(I studied the Russian Revolution in my final year of school), but that is just ghastly :|

That's the last time I act upon curiosity :lol:

As for the films, I would say Anastasia. It's not great, but it's much better than the other two abominations.
User avatar
pinkrenata
Anniversary Edition
Posts: 1915
Joined: Tue Oct 28, 2003 12:33 pm
Location: Mini Van Highway
Contact:

Post by pinkrenata »

bradhig wrote:Once Anastasia had been reunited with her grandmother Dimitri wasn't needed anymore.
But Dimitri's got great hair and a winning smile...
WIST #1 (The pinkrenata Edition) -- Kram Nebuer: *mouth full of Oreos* Why do you have a picture of Bobby Driscoll?

"I'm a nudist!" - Tommy Kirk
User avatar
Thumper_93
Gold Classic Collection
Posts: 395
Joined: Mon Aug 01, 2011 7:51 am
Location: España

Post by Thumper_93 »

i love both movies, are perfect, but Anastasia in my opinion it's more magnificent than The swan princess
Tae
Limited Issue
Posts: 64
Joined: Wed Jan 11, 2012 1:38 am

Post by Tae »

Anastasia is the best out of the three, I think, but I really like Thumbelina as well. It's cheesy, the plot flip flops too much and the character designs aren't great, but it was one of my favorites as a kid and so it has nostalgic value for me.
I only saw Swan Princess once, and I don't remember much from it, so I'm not sure about that one.

My only issue with Anastasia is that while the animation is very good, some of the movements look really awkward and forced. Especially the "Journey to the Past" sequence, Anya was skipping around so much I was waiting for her to fall headfirst into the snow.
User avatar
slave2moonlight
Diamond Edition
Posts: 4427
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 11:33 pm
Location: TX
Contact:

Post by slave2moonlight »

I really need to rewatch Anastasia and Thumbelina, not to mention see Swan Princess for the first time. I do have Anastasia on Blu, but I haven't watched it, and I bought Thumbelina last year on DVD, not anticipating a blu-ray release. *sigh* Swan Princess I keep intending to buy buy haven't yet. If I buy it, it's sure to come out on blu the next day.

Anyway, I still am pretty sure Anastasia is the best of these, and Thumbelina probably second best. I remember liking everything about Anastasia except the way they did the villain. Christopher Lloyd as Rasputin? Should have and could have been great, but they made it too cartoony and silly, and rather unimportant feeling. Though, again, I don't remember it super well. Thumbellina I remember not liking much overall, but it still was Don Bluth animation and Jodi Benson's voice... I really need to rewatch it. As for Swan Princess, I have seen bits and pieces on TV a lot, and it looked pretty unimpressive, despite a lovely lead character. I will reserve judgment on it though.

Incidentally, I keep seeing "We're Back" for 5 bucks. I really should buy it, but I know it's supposed to be terrible... Still, I do want it in my collection, and 5 bucks! For a while, it even had Lorax tickets (maybe it still does). Would have paid for itself since I went to see the Lorax anyway and paid full price... That was a dumb move, ha.
<a href="http://moonlightmotelcomic.com/"><img alt="Check out my published content!" src="http://fc09.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2012/ ... 4lxrtt.png" border="0"></a>
DisneyFan09
Platinum Edition
Posts: 3708
Joined: Mon Sep 21, 2009 2:28 pm

The Swan Princess vs. Anastasia

Post by DisneyFan09 »

Both films are musicals about Princesses and both of them really lies quite closely to the Disney formula, with a Princess, animals companions, a villain, ect. Heck, if it weren’t for the missing Disney logo, it would be easy to assume them to be Disney productions. But which of them do you prefer? And why?

Personally, I prefer “The Swan Princess”. I know many people prefer “Anastasia”, but I think it’s the more flawed of those two. While “Anastasia” has it’s moments, I think the film does have some serious flaws. The plot about a Princess with amnesia has many opportunities, yet the filmmakers play it safe. In fact, they play it too safe . Sure, it’s a kids movie, but even for a kid movie, the film is wrapped up after an half hour. As for the good components, the animation is good, the songs are really catchy and the voice acting is superb. Heck, Anastasia herself has more personality than the average Disney Princess. But as a whole, it’s not as good as it could have been.

While “Swan Princess” has less substance and depth than “Anastasia”, I think it’s a overall more enjoyable movie. The songs are catchy, the animation is good-looking, the voice acting is fine and the characters are likeable. Odette may not be such a sassy and fun heroine as Anastasia, but her sidekick companions are awesome. In fact, they’re better than Disney’s sidekick. While “Swan Princess” is not unflawed (in fact, the “love is beyond the appearance” plotline could have been more explored), I don’t think that it’s such a wasted potential as “Anastasia”.

What do you guys have to say about it?
Last edited by DisneyFan09 on Mon Apr 15, 2013 7:52 am, edited 1 time in total.
PatrickvD
Signature Collection
Posts: 5166
Joined: Fri Sep 19, 2003 11:34 am
Location: The Netherlands

Re: "Anastasia" vs. "The Swan Princess"

Post by PatrickvD »

The Swan Princess has good looking animation? Which movie did you see? :P

I'm no fan of Anastasia by any stretch of the animation but it is easily the superior film.
DisneyFan09
Platinum Edition
Posts: 3708
Joined: Mon Sep 21, 2009 2:28 pm

Re: "Anastasia" vs. "The Swan Princess"

Post by DisneyFan09 »

PatrickvD wrote:The Swan Princess has good looking animation? Which movie did you see? :P
OK, perhaps the visuals are not as superior as other animated flicks, but the animation is not that bad. Please don't answer in a sarcastic manner.
I'm no fan of Anastasia by any stretch of the animation but it is easily the superior film.
Why?
User avatar
Pokeholic_Prince
Gold Classic Collection
Posts: 187
Joined: Wed Aug 03, 2011 1:03 am
Location: USA
Contact:

Re: "Anastasia" vs. "The Swan Princess"

Post by Pokeholic_Prince »

"Anastasia" is by far the better of the two movies. It has gorgeous animation, songs that are not only catchy, but that have lyrical depth, and character that are fun and relateable. "Once Upon a December," and "Journey to the Past" are both hauntingly great songs. While, I think the villian could have been more fleshed out, he's still decent and has a pretty cool number.

"The Swan Princess" has decent animation, but nothing too spectacular. The charaters are okay, songs are meh, and the story is far too simple. Overall it's enjoyable, but dull to a certain extent.
DisneyFan09
Platinum Edition
Posts: 3708
Joined: Mon Sep 21, 2009 2:28 pm

Re: "Anastasia" vs. "The Swan Princess"

Post by DisneyFan09 »

Pokeholic_Prince wrote:"While, I think the villian could have been more fleshed out, he's still decent and has a pretty cool number.
Rasputin was another weak component on "Anastasia". While he at least started out as threatning and dignified in the prologue, he suddenly became whiny and pathetic during the rest of the movie. In other words; Not a dignified villain. While Rothbart in "Swan Princess" was unremarkable, he certainly wasn't as laughable as Rasputin.
User avatar
pinkrenata
Anniversary Edition
Posts: 1915
Joined: Tue Oct 28, 2003 12:33 pm
Location: Mini Van Highway
Contact:

Re: "Anastasia" vs. "The Swan Princess"

Post by pinkrenata »

Anastasia has Dimitiri. I don't know so much about that guy in The Swan Princess. On the other hand, there's also a lot of shoddy CGI animation...
WIST #1 (The pinkrenata Edition) -- Kram Nebuer: *mouth full of Oreos* Why do you have a picture of Bobby Driscoll?

"I'm a nudist!" - Tommy Kirk
User avatar
bradhig
Anniversary Edition
Posts: 1109
Joined: Thu Apr 07, 2005 10:59 pm
Location: Olathe , Kansas

Re: "Anastasia" vs. "The Swan Princess"

Post by bradhig »

Did Don Bluth work on the Swan Princess? I know he worked on Anastasia.
User avatar
Elladorine
Diamond Edition
Posts: 4372
Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2006 1:02 pm
Location: SouthernCaliforniaLiscious SunnyWingadocious
Contact:

Re: "Anastasia" vs. "The Swan Princess"

Post by Elladorine »

Hmm, I need to dig out both and have an non-Disney Disney-style marathon. :milkbuds: Maybe I'll throw Ferngully in for good measure.
pinkrenata wrote:Anastasia has Dimitiri.
Well, The Swan Princess has Jack Palance. No comparison there. :wink:
bradhig wrote:Did Don Bluth work on the Swan Princess? I know he worked on Anastasia.
No, it was directed by Richard Rich, who also directed The Black Caudron and helped direct The Fox and the Hound. :)
Image
Post Reply