I have a similar feeling about it, too.DisneyDude2010 wrote:Hmmm.... I don't like the idea of a pixar character in the lineup sorry! The line up should only consist of WDAS characters in my opinion, It just mixes up the identity of each character and the legacy of both studios! Plus I think that the message in Brave and Merida's rebellion would not fit in to the line up and match the morals of such characters like Snow White. And besides I bet Pixar never intended Brave to be a Disney Princess movie in the first place
Merida (to me at least), is the product of a new mentality when it comes to princess characters. Merida is proud to be a girl, she wishes to be free, see the world and be independent. She is proof that people can be happy without having to desire a love interest. The whole movie is about her trying to escape herself from the frills and rules of being a princess, which the Disney Princess line wholly embraces. Heck, her regular dress isn't even THAT frilly, not even the one they use for the Meridas at the Disney parks.
So having her alongside the likes of Cinderella, Belle and Rapunzel would be weird, since the majority of these characters are romantic in their endeavors and beliefs, which contrast greatly from Merida's brash and adventurous spirit.
To give an example of what I am talking about, here are Amy Mebberson's drawings on the subject matter:
But at the same time, I do see her being a very popular Disney Princess for the same reasons I stated: she is different. Remember how they made a big deal over Tiana because the line finally represented African American girls? Well, I see Merida as being the representation of girls that love being girls, but don't want to be stuck with all the rules about what women should be in life.
Plus, Merida has been a huge hit with people that are usually Anti-Princess because of her attitude. Merida stands in a very ideal place: she is a princess proud of her land, heritage and life, but also believes that her role in life is something bigger than marriage.
I think that's why Disney would want her in their lineup: she represents a progress of character.