Hurt or Heal The Hunchback of Notre Dame ESMERALDA WINS

[PixarFan2006]

Esmeralda - 20
Judge Claude Frollo - 11 (+1)
Quasimodo - 0 (-1)

Eliminated
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

[thelittleursula]

Esmeralda - 20
Judge Claude Frollo - 9 (-2)

Eliminated
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

[Sotiris]

Esmeralda - 20
Judge Claude Frollo - 7 (-2)

Eliminated
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

[Kraken Guard]

Esmeralda - 19 (-1)
Judge Claude Frollo - 8 (+1)

Eliminated
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

~~~~~
... Probably makes me a bad person, doesn't it?

[TheSequelOfDisney]

Esmeralda - 19
Judge Claude Frollo - 10 (+2)

Eliminated
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

[Jay]

Esmeralda - 19
Judge Claude Frollo - 8 (-2)

Eliminated
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

[ProfessorRatigan]

Esmeralda - 19
Judge Claude Frollo - 10 (+2)

Eliminated
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

@Mooky. Quasimodo's father, I would assume, means the Gypsy man with Quasimodo's Mother at the beginning of the film. "Shut it up, will you! We'll be spotted!" But I don't think that's his father, personally. I doubt a father would refer to his child, regardless of deformity, as an 'it.' (Frollo not withstanding. ) I'm honestly surprised he made it on the list instead of Achilles, Phoebus's horse, or even Snowball*, Frollo's horse, (both of whom have quite a personality. Watch the film again and pay attention to the horses when they're around each other. They can't stand one another.) Frollo also seems to have a bit of affinity for Snowball. When Phoebus steals the horse in his escape attempt, what's Frollo's response? "Get him, but don't hit my horse!" See, he has redeeming qualities after all!

*the name Snowball, while not referenced IN the film, is what fans of the film have taken to calling the horse, because the filmmakers themselves called him that in their audio commentary.

I'm honestly really disappointed that it looks like Frollo is going to lose to Esmeralda of all characters... If he HAD to lose, I'd rather it have been to Clopin or Quasimodo. (Speaking of which, why the hell was Clopin eliminated so early!?)

[Disney's Divinity]

I'm honestly really disappointed that it looks like Frollo is going to lose to Esmeralda of all characters... If he HAD to lose, I'd rather it have been to Clopin or Quasimodo. (Speaking of which, why the hell was Clopin eliminated so early!?)

I agree. Esmeralda would be the blandest character in the film if Phoebus weren’t there. Clopin and Frollo (and, to a lesser extent, the Archdeacon) are the only good characters in this movie to me. But a bad winner for a bad movie doesn’t bother me so much.

Esmeralda - 17 (-2)
Judge Claude Frollo - 10

Eliminated
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

[Kraken Guard]

Aww, I wouldn't go that far as to say that Esmeralda was bland! Even without Phoebus, I'm sure she would have been a good character.

~~~~~

Esmeralda - 15 (-2)
Judge Claude Frollo - 10

Eliminated
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

[universALLove]

Esmeralda - 15
Judge Claude Frollo - 8 (-2)

Eliminated
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

[TheSequelOfDisney]

Esmeralda - 15
Judge Claude Frollo - 10 (+2)

Eliminated
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

[thelittleursula]

C'mon Esmeralda guurl you can do it.



Esmeralda - 15
Judge Claude Frollo - 8 (-2)

Eliminated
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

[universALLove]

C'mon Esmeralda guurl you can do it.

Hopefully she'll wallop the dirty old letch across the back of his head with her tambourine and make sweet music in the process

[Sotiris]

Esmeralda - 15
Judge Claude Frollo - 6 (-2)

Eliminated:
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

[ProfessorRatigan]

Esmeralda - 15
Judge Claude Frollo - 8 (+2)

Eliminated:
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

[Jay]

I don't see how you can call Esmeralda bland. I think she is one of the better Disney heroines. I personally wanted Quasi to win but oh well. And I didn't have "Quasimodo's father" on my original list somebody else added him. I forgot about the horses.

Esmeralda - 15
Judge Claude Frollo - 6 (-2)

Eliminated:
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

[universALLove]

Esmeralda - 15
Judge Claude Frollo - 4 (-2)

Eliminated
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

[Sotiris]

Esmeralda - 15
Judge Claude Frollo - 2 (-2)

Eliminated:
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo

[Mooky]

Esmeralda - 15
Judge Claude Frollo - 0 (-2) ELIMINATED

Good riddance to the sniffy perv!



Eliminated:
Brutish Guard
Hugo
Oafish Guard
Quasimodo's Father
The Old Heretic
Clopin
The Archdeacon
Phoebus
Victor
Quasimodo's Mother
Laverne
Quasimodo
Judge Claude Frollo

@Mooky. Quasimodo's father, I would assume, means the Gypsy man with Quasimodo's Mother at the beginning of the film. "Shut it up, will you! We'll be spotted!" But I don't think that's his father, personally. I doubt a father would refer to his child, regardless of deformity, as an 'it.' (Frollo not withstanding. )

Yeah, I figured as much. No way that's his father, it's just some random Gypsy. If that man was supposed to be his father, I'm pretty sure it would have been a well-known fact.

I'm honestly surprised he made it on the list instead of Achilles, Phoebus's horse, or even Snowball*, Frollo's horse, (both of whom have quite a personality. Watch the film again and pay attention to the horses when they're around each other. They can't stand one another.)

I never noticed that! Now I have a reason to rewatch the film for the umpteenth time .

[Sotiris]

Good riddance to the sniffy perv!